Analysis
Requirements
Analysis is being conducted to ensure that the following requirements placed on MidSTAR are met:
- Frequency of first mode greater than 35 Hz
- Able to withstand 10.6 g's in all directions at once for launch
- Factor of safety greater than 1.25 / margin of safety greater than 0.25
From the mission statement:
"MidSTAR is intended to be a relatively low-cost, quick response platform,
accommodating small payloads approved by the DoD Space Experiments Review Board
(SERB) and awaiting launch through STP."
In order to achieve this goal, the MidSTAR team opted to forgo detailed stress
analysis relying instead on a robust test program to verify the strength and
reliability of the structure design. To mitigate the risk of a test
failure, experienced engineers, technicians and machinists were consulted with
throughout the design process.
Derivation of design loads: ESPA class payload users guide
Coupled loads analysis: TBS by launch vehicle provider
Analysis Status
The following analysis has been done to date:
FEM bending modes (first ten)
Hand calculations for stress in decks and side panels (see table below)
| Factor of Safety/Margin of Safety Table For Hand Calculations and FEM Results | ||||||||
| Required FOS: 1.25 | ||||||||
| Required MOS: 0.25 | ||||||||
| Required launch load (minimum): 10.6 g's | ||||||||
| Fastener Analysis: | ||||||||
| Scenario | mass (kg) | g's | preload % | # bolts | mu | FOS | ||
| Battery box, loaded in all three directions at once | 11.26 | 15 | N/A | 4 | N/A | 19.1 | ||
| Battery box, loaded in shear only, with friction | 11.26 | 15 | 0.5 | 4 | 0.5 | 17.2 | ||
| MidSTAR, friction calc to ensure it won't "rack" | 120 | 15 | 0.5 | 12 | 0.5 | 14.5 | ||
| Static Loads: | ||||||||
| Max allowable stress (Pa) | Actual Max Stress (Pa) | MSu | MSt | |||||
| Shelf with heaviest load (shelf with battery box) | 1.50E+08 | 1.37E+08 | 0.53 | 0.37 | ||||
| Side Panel | 4.49E+04 | 2.53E+04 | 1.49 | |||||
| Finite Element Model: | ||||||||
| First Mode frequency | Minimum | FOS | ||||||
| 72.1 Hz | 35 Hz | 2.06 | ||||||
The following equations were used to calculate margins of safety:
MSu = (FSu * Ftu) / Fact -1 > 0
MSy = (FSu * Fty) / Fact -1 > 0
Where
Msu is the ultimate strength margin of safety
Fsu is the factor of safety for ultimate strength (Fsu=1.4 for aluminum structure)
Msy is the yield strength factor of safety
Fsy is the factor of safety for yield strength (Fsy=1.25 for aluminum structure)
The following analysis and testing remains to be completed:
- Pull Test on the threaded inserts
- Pull Test on the bolts
- Friction Test to determine the actual coefficient of friction
- Venting Analysis
- Coupled Loads analysis
- Vibration Analysis
- Separation System Analysis
';